“Neglect Shames Britain”

I have often criticised the “Daily Mail” for it’s over sensational headlines, particularly those that raise unnecessary fears for older people.  The title of this blog is their front page headline of the 2nd December and for that they deserve CONGRATULATIONS!  More so because it was followed up the next day with a double page spread and a £50,000 donation to the Patients’ Association.  Then on 4th December yet another double page spread (albeit by now relegated to pages 20 and 21), this time with politicians and celebrities jumping on board – from Andrew Lansley, the Minister of Health and Stephen Dorrell, a former Health Secretary to Jack Charlton, Ulrika Jonsson, Carol Vorderman, Duncan Bannatyne, Ann Widdecombe, Simon Cowell, Esther Rantzen (obviously none of them just wanting to step in the limelight of publicity).

The touch-paper of this “campaign” was lit by a report from the Patients’ Association which focussed on the significant increase in complaints about the care of older people in the NHS.  This is far from a new issue, but it is one that has fallen on deaf ears so many times in the past.  Let’s hope the legacy of Claire Raynor, who was until recently, President of the Patients’ Association, will put wind under the wings of this initiative. 

They are a very small organisation who deserve the highest praise for managing to raise the profile of this issue on behalf of thousands of older people, past and present.  The challenge for them now is can they keep up the momentum, and are they able to resource themselves, both financially and strategically to promote a major change in health care.

If we go back to the source of this issue, it is a rise in complaints about elderly patient care to over 5,000 a year.  A number which has doubled since 2008, and will almost certainly be on the tip of an iceberg of real concern by residents and their relatives.  Many patients are reluctant to complain, either for fear of stimulating a negative reaction or because they have no confidence anything will change.

The NHS management and the medical professions are renowned for their defensiveness when criticised.  Yet many of the complaints highlighted in the report are indefensible:-

  • Failing to feed people
  • Failing to give them a drink
  • Failing to provide personal care
  • Failing to give relief from pain
  • Not providing dignity or respect

All these things are at the lowest level of meeting Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, are the very basics of good nursing care.  They are neither expensive nor technologically difficult to provide, so why are they so frequently not available?

Step out of the NHS box for a minute and imagine we were talking about DOGS.  Dogs that were not fed or given water; dogs that were never groomed or washed; dogs that were left sitting in their own urine and faeces; dogs knowingly left in pain.  There would quite rightly be uproar.  Neighbours would report owners to the RSPCA.  The RSPCA would step in and take over care of the dogs.  The dogs’ health care would promptly be attended to.  Prosecution of the previous carers may well follow.  Widespread neglect would attract the attention of animal rights campaigners and the general public would be fully behind them.

Perhaps the key difference is that pet care is provided by owners and animal support organisations, either voluntarily or through charitable donations.  There is little Government support or intervention in support for pets.

You have to ask if the malaise which affects the lack of care of the elderly rather than blaming the medical carers on the wards, really starts at the top with the Government.  Successive Governments have consistently under-funded elderly care while simultaneously increasing the burden of legislation that bears down on the care sector.  I will write more about this later.

In the meantime, let’s wish well and God speed to this Patients Association report and Daily Mail campaign.  Is £100,000 anything like enough – shouldn’t it be at least £1m?  And will independent matrons really be able to turn around an elderly, careless NHS culture?

More later, what do you think?

This entry was posted in ELDERLY UK POLICY and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to “Neglect Shames Britain”

  1. Vicar says:

    before I mount my charger, and my mind conks out, or indeed climb aboard my soapbox! The day is 16th. the month December the year 2010; I wish to express the following to all the readers of this column: ‘A very merry Christmas and a Happy New Year’. Many more moments of giggles and exasperation in 2011 for the writers who dare to contribute to this most enlightened of Bloggs.

    • John says:

      Many thanks for the kind comments. I am glad you like the blogs.
      Your comments are always interesting and add to my thoughts.

      Seasons Greetings John

  2. Andy Bradley says:

    Thankyou for throwing light on the issues around ageing and care. Having grown up around older people who were treated with the utmost respect and compassion by my parents in the care home we all lived in I am sure that we are not tackling the need for change from the right angle. I agree that the Patients Association are doing incredibly valuable work by highlighting the neglect and abuse that too many older people suffer, but as has been proved by the repeated scandals, investigations and dictats over the last 15 years the culture that creates apparent indifference is stubbornly difficult to change.
    My sense is that we should change tack now and stop trying to ‘stamp out neglect and abuse’ and instead focus our energies on the cultivation of kindness and compassion as most people who are paid to care do so becuase they want to be good and and to make a positive difference – we need to change the narrative and the community script about the care of older people by throwing light on the factors at play in the best of care and support. Frameworks 4 Change, an organisation I set up 6 years ago to bring about deep culture change recently produced a film called ‘Knowing You Matter’ in which older people in care and nursing homes speak honestly with courage about their lives and the simple values they would like to experience in the way they are cared for.
    The film has been very well recieved and is being used in various environments to enable care givers to refelct on the values that underpin the most respectful support for older people. We now want to make a second film called ‘Showing You Matter’ which will focus on the question ‘when it is good, why is it good’ so that we can showcase and celebrate the most human and community oriented care and support for older people and spread the best work and most inspiring stories to accelerate a positive change.

    My connection to your blog is also more personal as my mum (who is my lifelong teacher!) supports a particularly talented and unique man (among others) at the Rose Gardens in Hereford – i think you will know who i mean! Thankyou for the fantastic work at Extra Care – it has given mum (65 last week) a real lease of life and she is now rarely at home!! Mum and i talk on the phone most days and compare notes on what it takes to develop the best lives with whatever care and support is required.

    Do let me know if you would like to see Knowing You Matter or to share thoughts furthur on making positive change and seeing more smiles!

    wishing you and your family a wonderful chrsitmas and 2011.

    thankyou for all that you have done and for continuing on this path.

    warmest regards
    Andy (Bradley)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s